Hahn faces tough decisions on A.J., Peavy, Youkilis

Hahn faces tough decisions on A.J., Peavy, Youkilis
October 26, 2012, 10:44 pm

Rick Hahn will have to make difficult decisions on a World Series hero who gave the White Sox an identity and a hard edge, as well as the Cy Young Award winner who underwent experimental surgery, not to mention: Youk!

Thats just the start of the offseason dominoes still waiting to fall on the South Side.

Hahn took timeout for the news conference announcing his promotion to general manager, but said afterward that budget meetings were still happening on Friday at U.S. Cellular Field. While the White Sox havent settled on a final payroll number for next year, preliminary projections gave him confidence that it would be right in the same neighborhood we spent in 2012, somewhere around 100 million.

A.J. Pierzynski is positioned to become a free agent, while the White Sox are expected to decline options on Jake Peavy and Kevin Youkilis, seeing if they can work out another deal. They also hold club options on pitchers Gavin Floyd (9.5 million) and Brett Myers (10 million with a 3 million buyout), with Francisco Liriano about to hit free agency.

Hahn believes Tyler Flowers will be an everyday catcher in the big leagues, which could spell the end for Pierzynski, who was on the verge of signing with the Los Angeles Dodgers in December 2010 before the White Sox stepped in with a two-year, 8 million deal.

I try not to handicap these things at this point, Hahn said. Weve had A.J. here for eight years and hes been a fantastic member of the White Sox organization for every minute of it. Weve signed him to I think three multiyear deals in the course of those eight years. Two years ago at this time, I think there was probably a thick level of pessimism about him coming back.

A source indicated that Pierzynski had lunch with chairman Jerry Reinsdorf after the season ended, while Hahn said he spoke with the catchers agent last week.

It was a good dialogue, and an open dialogue, and well stay in touch, Hahn said. Until he gets out there and sees what his market is and we get out there and sort of explore alternatives and other ways to spend our money its impossible to handicap. But I know there was pessimism this time two years ago, so I dont get too caught up in whatever pessimism there is now.

Pierzynski is 35 years old and coming off a season in which he generated 27 homers and 77 RBI. Peavy also made a salary drive, returning to the All-Star Game and going 11-12 with a 3.37 ERA while accounting for 32 starts and 219 innings.

Look, there arent a lot of free-agent pitchers out there, and there is a fair amount of money that has to be spent by other clubs, Hahn said. Pitchers get paid a significant amount and Jake given his track record and especially his 2012 season where he answered questions about his health is going to be a pretty popular guy.

So that one may be a challenge, but weve had good talks back and forth already, honest conversations. I know Jakes preference which he hasnt been shy about is to be back here in Chicago. And thats always a good place to start. But there does come a point where there are certain opportunities elsewhere that dont make sense for us to try to chase.

It sounds like emotions wont get in the way this time. Of the top 10 moments during his 12 years as assistant general manager, Hahn estimated that Mark Buehrle might have been responsible for three or four of them. But that didnt mean the White Sox should match the four-year, 58 million contract the Miami Marlins gave the veteran left-hander last winter.

Hahn believes the White Sox should compete for a playoff spot next season and win multiple World Series titles. Hes inheriting a team that should have Chris Sale and John Danks near the front of the rotation, and Adam Dunn, Paul Konerko and Alex Rios in the middle of the order. Theyre running out of room for more big-ticket items.

This is an opportunity for a lot of these players, as their first time out on the open market, Hahn said. Understandably, they want to hear from the other 29 clubs and may be interested in what their value is. Given the sort of shallowness of this years free agent market and the fact that there are some clubs with some money to spend, Im not overly optimistic that were going to be huge players in free agency.

But at the same time, were going to be out there looking for values and certainly continue to talk to our guys and see if we cant fit them in for next year, too.